The Highlander immigrants who helped build America

The Highlands of Scotland proved to be a natural recruiting ground for emigrants that were to help build North America during the 18th and 19th centuries.

Many Highlanders left Scotland in the 18th century. Picture: Wikimedia/ CC
Many Highlanders left Scotland in the 18th century.

The breakdown of Highland society and culture created bleak prospects on home soil for ordinary folk while the revered fighting powers of the clans made their men sought after recruits for the British Army fighting the American Revolution.

From Georgia to North Carolina and New York, here we look at those from the North of Scotland who were tempted across the Atlantic – whether through desperate need or the dream of a better life.

Highland life was tough and many sought a better life in the new world. Picture: Creative Commons
Highland life was tough and many sought a better life in the new world. Picture: Creative Commons

THE FIRST ARRIVALS

Wanted: Industrious, laborious and brave Gaelic speaking Highlanders to populate the newly established colony of Georgia.

It was 1735 with two Scots, Lieutenant Hugh Mackay and Captain George Dunbar, issuing the rallying call after being hired by Georgia’s trustees to find men suitable to defend frontiers against Spain and France and to make their 20-acre lands productive.

The Highlands, whose men had been both feared and lauded for their strength and fighting power, was a natural hunting ground for the soldiers.

Lanark and District Pipe Band lead New York's Tartan Day Parade.
Lanark and District Pipe Band lead New York’s Tartan Day Parade.

The Provost of Inverness, John Hossack – also a merchant and trader – was to help fund the boats to transport the men with Mackay launching a successful recruitment campaign in his home patch of Caithness and Sutherland. Dunbar successfully recruited from Clan Chattan.

Professor Marjory Harper, author and historian, said 260 men sailed to North America in three contingents between 1735 and 1741 with the first lot setting up the township of Darien on the reconstruct the clan system on the other side of the Atlantic r – named possibly in defiance of the failed Panama scheme.

Professor Harper said; “The Highlanders did pretty well there and the trustees were pleased with what they did. A second contingent went in 1737 and a third in 1741.

“This all helped to publicise opportunity in this magical new land across the Atlantic.”

CAPE FEAR – OR THE ARGYLL COLONY

They boarded a ship in Argyllshire, 350 Highland Scots bound for Brunswick Town, North Carolina. They came by choice, looking for land to stake their claim in the new World. Over the next century came thousands more, defeated at Culloden, punished by the English Government and “cleared” off their lands ” by their chiefs. Most spoke no English, they dressed in the manner of the Gaels, and were not welcomed by the English on the coast. They went forth up the river and made new lives along the Cape Fear.

Cape Fear River Print from an original hand painted and | Etsy | Retro map  art, Retro map, Cape fear

Cape Fear in North Carolina become home to around 1,200 Jacobite prisoners following the 1715 and 1745 uprisings. The fighters were the bedrock of this new community later to be known as the Argyll Colony, which attracted an estimated 20,000 Scots in the eight years before the American Revolution.

Immigration - Lessons - Blendspace

Around 350 Scots arrived in 1739 on board The Thistle and, according to the Journal of the North Carolina Scottish Heritage Society, a second and larger wave of migration began to flood the Cape Fear valley with people from Arran, Jura, Islay and Gigha.

The Highlanders did not mix easily with the other groups in the area such as the English, Irish, Scots-Irish, Germans, or the smaller groups of Huguenots, Welsh, and Swiss. They preferred to live among those who spoke their language and shared their customs, and usually settled in groups.

Professor Harper said: “At the time, Argyllshire was at the vanguard of commercialization of estates. People were feeling dislocated at home, rents were going up, they were being treated in a far more hard nosed way by estate owners. That paternalism had gone.”

NPG 5848; Flora Macdonald - Portrait - National Portrait Gallery
Flora MacDonald

Perhaps the most famous Scot to settle in North Carolina was Flora MacDonald, the woman who aided Bonnie Prince Charlie in his departure from Scotland. MacDonald and her husband Allan arrived in 1774 having lost 300 head of cattle in the three years before their departure. Her husband would go on to fight for the British Army in the American Revolution.

A BLURRED LINE

Professor Harper said there was often an “ambiguity” between military and civilian recruitment of Highlanders at a time when the British Government sought loyalists to fight the Revolution. Tacksmen, the lynch pins of the old clan systems and chief organizers of men for war, became key figures in the British Army in mid-18th Century as the military role of the clans was banished by the British Government following Culloden.

Harper said: “Many of them responded to the loss of status by entering the British Army as officers. “This was one of the ironies or the repercussions of Jacobitism. From the mid 18th Century, the feared warlike Highland clans became a major pillar in support for the British Army. “Many of them were placed to lead imperial units and part of their reward for military service was grants of land. The Tacksmen were well placed to get their tenants from back home.

“Military officers returned home to recruit settlers for their land grants, leading to the creation of concentrated clusters of Highland landownership for strategic parts of Great British North America.

Culloden

“They could basically reconstruct the clan system on the other side of the Atlantic.”

The British Government was therefore seen as an agent of Highland emigration but later became concerned that the new Highland recruits would switch allegiances on arrival in North America.

Greater scrutiny of those leaving Scottish shores was therefore required.

THE REGISTER

A nationwide effort to survey every emigrant who officially left Scotland and England for North America between December 1773 and March 1776 was undertaken.

Harper said that government disquiet at emigration was at its peak in Scotland, with tradesmen threatening to leave if they did not get higher wages and claims that people willingly committed crimes in the hope of transportation.

The Register of Emigrants shows that 3,872 people left Scotland in the period with clusters from Perth, Inverness followed by Ross and Cromarty, Arygll and Renfrew.

Agriculture in Scotland in the Middle Ages - Wikipedia
Threshing and pig feeding from a book of hours from the Workshop of the Master of James IV of Scotland (Flemish, c. 1541)

Most of the Highlanders were agriculturalists, Harper, chair of history at Aberdeen University, said.

She added: “The Register contains almost twice as many negative as positive statements among the Scots, particularly among emigrants from the Highlands and Islands and the western lowlands.”

However, two out of five Scottish emigrants whose motives were recorded spoke positively about their decision to leave – particularly if they came from higher up the social scale,

Scots settled mainly in North Carolina and New York, according to the Register. Around nine percent of those who went to New York were listed as indentured servants, with the rate falling to one per cent for those heading to North Carolina, where linking up families was the main reason for going. The Register – analyzed by historian Viola Cameron – also shows 106 passengers travelled from Stornoway to Philadelphia in May 1774 all of whom emigrated “in order to procure a living abroad, as they were quite destitute of bread at home.”

A group from Strathspey reported being driven out by “high rents and deerness (sic) of provisions.” Another set from Argyllshire told researchers “they would never have thought of leaving their native country, could they have supplied their families in it. “But such of them as were farmers were obliged to quit their lands either on account of the advanced rent or to make room for shepherds.” The British Government was so alarmed that it banned emigration to North America for the duration of the American Revolution, which ended 1783.

After the ban was lifted, US remained a key destination for emigrants until 1909.

Amongst those arriving were those forced out by the Highlands Clearance. While the majority of exiles ended up in Canada, some found the Carolinas to be their final destination.

Many Highland drovers immigrated and became cattlemen and helped establish the great cattle trails of the western United States and Australia.

A regular traffic of men from Sutherland to work the ranches of Montana was also recorded in the late 1890s with some evidence that the workforce was around 50 per cent Gaelic speaking Scots and 50 per cent native Americans. Their impact of the Scots on language and music has been researched by Rob Gibson in his book Highland Cowboys, from the Hills of Scotland to the American Wild West.

LEGACY

Of the fifty-six Signers of the Declaration of Independence, 19 can claim to have Scottish ancestry. Meanwhile, only 10 of the 42 presidents of the United States can claim to have no Scottish heritage at all. Future steel industrialist and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie arrived in New York from Dunfermline in 1848, aged 13. John Muir, the father of the US national parks movement, arrived from Dunbar the following year. However, Harper cautioned against Scottish “exceptionalism” and said that Scots were part of a “melting pot” of new arrivals. She said: “Scots certainly had a big influence but they are part of a bigger jigsaw of lots of nations.”

Declaration of Independence | Summary, Definition, Date, & Text | Britannica
John Trumbull: Declaration of IndependenceDeclaration of Independence, oil on canvas by John Trumbull, 1818; in the U.S. Capitol Rotunda, Washington, D.C.
Architect of the Capitol

From 1909, it was Canada that was overwhelmingly favored by Scots seeking out new life across the Atlantic. In the 1920s, the peak of Scottish emigration, more than 363,000 Scots left for the USA and Canada in a single decade.

Published by Clan Carruthers Society - USA

We are all passionate about where we came from and where we're going. We set this website/blog up so we can all share our family stories along with the history for future generations.

One thought on “The Highlander immigrants who helped build America

  1. I think this is one of the most vital info for me. And i am glad reading your article. But want to remark on some general things, The web site style is wonderful, the articles is really nice : D. Good job, cheers

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: